Sunday, September 30, 2012

A Modest Proposal

This week in English 102, Our class assignment was to read and respond to the following set of

questions in Johnathan Swift's article, " A Modest Proposal".


http://www.proprofs.com/games/jigsaw/upload/686847_1319145538.jpg


 

Question 1:

           The problem that Swift identifies in his society is that women are having babies that can’t even

Support, let alone have the ability to provide for ones child in Ireland. I think Swift considers an

alternative idea of selling the children as slaves, not only does he promote this idea but he asks the

women to "Bulk-up" there child so they can later sell their child to the wealthy. I personally thought

that this idea could evolve into the same situation repeatedly.

Question 2:

           I believe Swifts suggestion was not to be taken seriously because babies were not only sold but

we’re being eaten. The purpose was leaning toward an example that this could be a way of life

if you can’t provide for your family. Swift was making fun of his society to grab Irelands government

attention about this issue that has been ignored for some time now.

Question 3:

          I do believe this situation is logical because women in this society don’t have the money and

support to take care of their child so they have to think of alternative ways to survive. The evidence

that Swift gives to support his position is that babies should not be sold to the wealthy or eaten for

food but be raised by responsible parents who can afford to support them.

3 comments:

  1. Brooke, first off I want to say awesome background! You have a really good image and link. Your post is very simple but to the point. Its short and sweet making it easy for the reader to follow along. I liked how you set up your post, so I followed suit. I however don't find the situation to be logical. It seems crazy to me! Great job!

    ReplyDelete
  2. That is too funny, we chose the same image but mine is in black and white! Im sorry to say but I dont like how you had your post all blocked out into questions. I believe the assignment was supposed to be more like an analysis while answering the questions in that. I do have to agree that Swift was very logical and he made great points to prove that. Dont go out making babies if you cant afford to raise them! To goes for today's society too! ;)
    (Terri Snyder)

    ReplyDelete
  3. I really liked the format you did in answering the questions. I thought it was very clear in the fact you stated what questions you would be answering for each one. Also it seems like you had a clear understanding about the story, and about what satire is.

    ReplyDelete